Smooth Criminal or Smooth Singer
Record information about the cover song you choose—including title, author, and date. Be sure to include link to blog post.
Smooth Criminal, Glee- Naya Rivera and Grant Gustin (2012)
Record Information about the original song– Including title, author, and date. Be sure to include link to blog post.
Smooth Criminal- Michael Jackson (1987)
In 250 words, discuss the differences between the original and the cover. Be specific about lyrics, instrumentation, pace/rhythm, vocal emphasis and other considerations.
The original was built for a movie. In this sense, he was already famous. He had been famous as a child and as a solo artist adult as well. In the beginning, Michael Jackson whispered slightly, spoke quickly and keep it almost secretive. Throughout the song though he got louder and more prominent. His voice is hoarse and some parts get pronounced more sharply. The accompanying music is more technical, it includes synthesizers, drums, guitar and a variety of other instruments. The general pace of the song is fast. Michael’s version is very funky, and very 80s themed, probably since it was introduced within this decade. There are multiple parts that included pauses in the song for the inclusions of the movie parts, but also for dancing. The accompanying video is very violent, dark, and filled with background people. There is a lot of featured dancing by all the people in the video. In comparison, the Glee version is much different. Although Glee had already been famous for their covers, the two starts, Rivera and Gustin, had not exactly been famous for covering songs especially together. Their version is more pronounced. They been and finish the song very strong, with Rivera taking more of the strong background parts and Gustin doing more of the chorus and lyrical parts. The music that is behind their voices is solely by two cellos, this is drastically different from Michael Jackson’s technological sound. They do sing the songs as quick as Michael Jackson does. Their song comes off as more of a duel between the two sings, this is mostly likely because of what is going in the plot of the episode the song is featured in. In the video, their movements flow with the song in room full of chairs with only them and the cello players. The lyrics remained the same in both versions.
List and define three contextual considerations that shape the mode of the cover song/artist.
- Context: Instrumentation: difference between the technological sounds and the cellos.
- Context: Vocals: the addition of a female in a song that was typically song by one male.
- Context: Context of Song; Micahel’s was in a movie and included aspects of the movie while the Glee version featured a duel between the singers because of the context of the episode.
Choose one of the above contextual considerations and discuss how it may have helped determine the artist’s approach in 250 words.
The difference in context between the Glee club version and the original song, sung by Michael Jackson is huge in this song. The video is much longer for Michael’s version because of his break in the song for dancing, movie scenes and more. Clearly, there is a story line in the video. He includes other people because they’re potentially movie characters and important ones that needed to be included. His version is also more dark. In the Glee version, the episode relates around a problem with an outside character that involved the male singer in the video, Grant Gustin. Naya Rivera’s character steps in and addresses the problem with Gustin’s character to protect her other friend. This causes the two singers to challenge each other to a duel. I believe this causes a large amount of character within the song because of its ability to make the singers sound their competing. They both sing to their best ability while also doing their own styles and tone. It’s effective for their own purposes to help show their battle between them but it is also good for my analysis. Their dueling duet is completely different from what Michael Jackson does. He stars in it and adds a lot of texture to the song. Rivera and Gustin have different texture, but it works better for their situation. I think the context of the scene makes a large difference between the two. Glee is a duel while Michael Jackson’s version is more dark and involved.
In 250 words explain how this connects to the concept of remediation. What changes in the cover song led you to rethink the intent or driving motive of the original work? Was this remediation particularly effective? How/Why? Be specific.
The Glee version of the song Smooth Criminal was not completely different. They did change it to fit their purposes better. Despite that, the lyrics are still the same as the original version, sung by Michael Jackson. I believe that this changes a lot for the intent or driving motive of the original work. When listening to Michael Jackson’s version I do no necessarily get the vibe that he was trying to make a very tense song. After listening to Rivera and Gustin’s version, it is very clear that they are trying to create tension throughout the song. Now that I’ve heard it, I can hear the tension in Michael Jackson’s version. Now, I feel he might have had intent on it being like that as well. I think the Glee version remediation was effective. I enjoy listening to it on its own and it really feels like they are painting a story when you listen to it. The vocals between Rivera taking the background high notes and Gustin doing the fast paced chorus creates a really interesting texture. Their battle is really grabbing and the song makes me want to listen to it more. Then, it ends and I honestly cannot believe it is over. It’s very intense and builds a lot. This makes the song very intriguing and makes the listener want to finish the song and hear the story they paint until the end. Their rendition is very successful because they have the ability to do this.
.